• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Plush Horse Ice Cream Shop - Tinley Park | Delicious Homemade Ice Cream with Friendly Service

Plush Horse Ice Cream Shop in Tinley Park is a delightful haven for ice cream lovers seeking variety and quality. Located at 7903 W 171st St, this charming spot offers a vast array of homemade flavors, from classic to inventive like their standout key lime pie with graham cracker crumbs. The welcoming staff create a warm, family-friendly atmosphere, allowing guests to sample flavors freely and enjoy generous portions without feeling rushed. With ample seating and convenient parking, it’s perfect for a relaxed, sweet treat. This location blends exceptional flavors with attentive service, making every visit a memorable and satisfying experience.

Plush Horse Ice Cream Shop - Tinley Park at a glance

  • Address 7903 W 171st St, Tinley Park, IL 60477, United States
  • Phone +1 708-444-1800
  • Restaurant type Ice cream shop , Coffee shop .
  • Popular for Good for solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Plush Horse Ice Cream Shop - Tinley Park: Reviews & Ratings

Manè
5

How fun! So0o0o0o many flavors. I think the price is right! They servers were perfect gentlemen! They let my 6 kids & I sample a few flavors and the portions were outstanding. The flavors were incredible. Will definitely be returning.

Jackie
5

Awesome ice cream shop! They have so many flavors it's hard to make up your mind. My family loves coming here and staff is very welcoming. We always leave with a smile on our face. This place is a must when you have a sweet tooth!

Dina Karanikolas
5

This plush horse location is absolutely phenomenal. The staff there was beyond kind and friendly. Of course, all of their ice cream is homemade, so it goes without saying that, that was absolutely delicious. This time I enjoyed the key lime pie. Ice cream with Graham cracker crumbs in it. It was absolutely phenomenal. I would like to give a special shout out to the manager who went out of their way to help something to do with my kindergarten class. It was very nice of him. Thank you so much for being a great location. And having a great product and a great product and a great staff. Kudos to all of you.

Rey
5

I know the other location has more history and looks cooler and whatnot, but this location is better in my opinion. There's never a huge line and I can take my time reviewing options for me and the kids without worrying I'm holding up a line. Plenty of seating and the parking lot is fairly ample. Last but definitely not least, their ice cream is fantastic.

Chris Parent
5

Really Really good Ice Cream. My Wife and I went to this location for the first time, since the other location had a line down the block. I guess We had Our hearts set on some Plush Horse Ice Cream. Lol! We both enjoyed a cool treat on nice Summers evening

Melissa Gula
5

This place always has the most amazing flavors! Service is always friendly and with a smile too! This location opened a few years ago and doesn't disappoint! Not only a family favorite but now a family tradition!

Sam S
5

Friendly staff. high-quality, homemade ice cream, you can taste the difference. I love their pistachio flavor and Hawaiian delight.

3D M3NaYeZ
5

Decided to come here with a friend. Their cookies were delicious. Ended up purchasing a valentine cookie along with a sundae. The sundae consisted of Grasshopper flavored ice cream with gummy bears, hot fudge, and nuts. Aside from the treats and ice cream flavors, I really appreciated the customer service. When I first got the sundae, I noticed the gummy bears were missing on my sundae. When addressed this, one of the staff members fixed my order and it made my night. I’d come back again.

Location

  • Plush Horse Ice Cream Shop - Tinley Park
    Plush Horse Ice Cream Shop - Tinley Park
    7903 W 171st St, Tinley Park, IL 60477, United States Hotline: +1 708-444-1800

Nestled in the heart of Tinley Park at 7903 W 171st St, Plush Horse Ice Cream Shop offers a delightful escape for ice cream lovers seeking both variety and quality. This charming spot serves homemade ice cream, crafted with care and creativity, presenting an array of flavors that spark curiosity and satisfy every sweet tooth.

The menu at Plush Horse is a celebration of imaginative flavors and classic favorites alike. From the rich, nostalgic Cookie Dough Ice Cream and Cookies and Cream Cake to the unique Honey Lavender and Banana Fudge, each scoop tells a story. The Cookie Monster served in a crisp waffle cone is a playful treat that brings joy to kids and adults. For those who crave a richer indulgence, the Brownie Sundae or Hot Fudge Sundae delivers the perfect balance of creamy and decadent.

What truly sets this location apart is the welcoming atmosphere and thoughtful service. Customers often mention the staff's kindness and willingness to let guests sample various flavors, an experience that enhances the joy of discovery. Ample seating and a spacious parking lot provide comfort and convenience, encouraging visitors to linger and savor every bite.

Particularly noteworthy are the inventive combinations like the Strawberry Pineapple Sundae paired with Strawberry Cheesecake or the whimsical Cotton Candy and Bubble Gum Ice Creams. These flavors highlight Plush Horse’s commitment to creativity without sacrificing the smooth, rich texture that defines excellent ice cream.

The craftsmanship extends beyond single scoops to Ice Cream Cakes and milkshakes like the Grasshopper Shake, offering something special for celebrations or casual treats. The blend of traditional and innovative options ensures there's always a new flavor to try, making each visit a fresh experience.

After sampling the varied offerings, it’s clear that Plush Horse Ice Cream Shop - Tinley Park is much more than just an ice cream parlor. It’s a community hub where families come together, memories are made, and flavor adventures are embraced. Whether you’re craving the classic Pistachio Nut Ice Cream or the vibrant Blueberry and Cherry Vanilla topped with whipped cream, this shop is a sweet spot well worth the visit.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
  • Service options
    • Offers delivery
    • Has in-store shopping
    • Offers takeaway
    • Serves dine-in
    • Same-day delivery
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Accepts NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards